Skip to content
Illustration from the riddle “The Diver in the Forest”

Guides

Yes or no riddles: 12 dark stories to solve by asking questions

Illustration: The Diver in the Forest

Search for yes or no riddles and you mostly get one-liners such as “What question can you never answer yes to?”. This page is about the other kind, the one a whole table can spend twenty minutes on. Someone knows a short, strange story. Everyone else asks questions that can only be answered yes or no, until they have worked out what happened. They are also called situation puzzles or lateral thinking puzzles. Here are twelve, sorted from easy to hard, with the rules in a few lines. The scenes are here. The answers are not.

In this article

How a yes or no riddle works

One person, the narrator, knows the whole story and reads out its opening scene. The others ask closed questions, one at a time. The narrator answers yes, no or irrelevant, the third answer being for anything that makes no difference to the story. The riddle is solved when the table can tell what happened and explain every odd detail of the scene.

It is not Twenty Questions. There you guess a thing. Here you rebuild a story, and a wrong theory costs you nothing but one more “no”.

Four easy ones to start with

One star on our scale: drop a single assumption and the whole scene makes sense.

  • The Diver in the Forest: firefighters find a dead man in a burnt forest. He wears a wetsuit, a mask and fins. The sea is fifty miles away.
  • The Walled Yard: a woman is murdered in a yard behind high walls. No building overlooks it. Yet a witness saw the murder with his own eyes.
  • The Phantom Weapon: a man is stabbed to death in his flat. Nobody leaves the building, and the police find no blade.
  • Eight Taps: Berlin, 1904. Asked what three plus five makes, a horse taps his hoof eight times. Thirteen experts find no trick, yet he cannot count.

Four for a table that has played before

Two stars: two or three facts to find, then to connect.

  • The New Shoes: a woman buys new shoes and wears them straight to work. She does not trip. Within the hour, she is dead.
  • The Armchair Champion: two neighbours bet a dinner on whose watch counts more steps in a month. One walks two hours a day. The other, too lazy to leave his flat, wins.
  • Helmet to Helmet: two astronauts repair a panel outside the station. Their radios work fine. One presses his helmet against the other’s, and they stay like that for two minutes.
  • The Twelfth Body: a tug sinks. Three days later, divers bring up eleven bodies, and the twelfth grabs a diver’s hand.

Four hard ones

Three stars: a whole backstory to work back through, stage by stage. Hard means a longer road, not a trick, and none of them needs outside knowledge.

  • The Music Stops: the orchestra plays its last note. A moment later, a woman dies in front of hundreds of people, and nobody has touched her.
  • Dead on Paper: a man’s bank writes to say he has died. A registrar hands him a death certificate in his name. No typo, no namesake.
  • By Heart: shot by robbers, a shopkeeper dials in the dark. He has known his home number by heart for thirty years, and not one finger slips. The light would have saved him.
  • Göring’s Vermeer: Amsterdam, 1945. A painter is arrested for selling Göring a lost Vermeer, and he could be shot. He gets one year and becomes a national hero.

Where the answers are

Not on this page, and not on the riddles’ own pages either. Many people look these stories up for the answer, so here it is plainly: each solution is in the Post Mortem app, and opens once its case is closed, by your own questions or with clues, which open its facts one at a time.

We keep them off the web so that searching for a title never spoils the story for someone about to play it. If you want to run one for friends, close the case yourself first: the narrator’s guide says what to note down.

Nobody to ask?

A yes or no riddle needs someone who knows the answer. In the app, on iOS and Android, that someone is the narrator: you type your own questions, and it answers yes, no or irrelevant, and sends back any question that cannot be answered that way. There is a riddle of the day too.

Find a riddle to explore

Browse free opening scenes by theme or difficulty.